Ce qu'ecrivent nos grands penseurs

"Neg sot san fomasyon san ideal paka dirije peyi memsi li se desandan Dessalines ouswa pitit soyet .Pwen barr"Dezagreman.

Ki derespktan sa pou zanset nou yo;Toussaint Louverture ak Dessalines, ak Christophe ak Capois La mort te frekante iniversite ?Mwen pa vle rantre nan yon polemik initil ak personn non ,men mwen ta renmen yon moun di m sa Stenio Vincent ,Louis Borno, Surde Dartiguenave ,Elie Lescot ,Docteur Francois Duvalier,Gerard Latortue te remet nan gad la.Lè nou beswen bafwe moun pouki sa nou ekri nan yon forum piblik?

Ki donk Jean Claude Duvalier pi entelijan ou byen pi byen edike ke ni Preval ni Jacques Edouard Alexis, Ni Verella.Kanta pou Docteur Arsitide menm se bliye sa se pa la Sorbonne li pran diplom li yo .Koumatiboulout 'education se yon bagay ki relatif vre.Duvalier ki yonn nan presidan ayisyen ki pi byen edike eske li te fè plis pou peyi ya ke Antoine Simon?HarryTruman pat dirije Eta Zuni?Nikita kruschev pat dirije lUnion Sovyetik ,Leflowenza,mwen bliye non li pat dirje la poloy?Hitler pat dirje lalmay .mussolini pat dirije litali.?Mezanmi di doktè ya sa nou soufri pou yo geri nou.Nou sabote gouvenman pep la tout jan epi nou di ke se demokrasi nap defann.Pouki nou pa di se yon plutocratie de yon elit repiyan ke nou vle enstale nan peyi Dessalines lan.

Se pa pale de lespri nou ;de konesans nou; montre sa nou te fè. "Show me the money."Menm Jean Claude fè mea culpa li ,mwen ta konprann nou tou ta frape lestomak nou pou nou mande pep ayisyen an padon pou mal nou fè peyi ya.Men nou pito ap ekri franseuu , anploye gwo mo pou nou fè pov despri ponpe.

Dezagreman di: "

Neg sot san fomasyon san ideal paka dirije peyi memsi li se desandan Dessalines ouswa pitit soyet .Pwen barr".

Sepa avoka di dyab ke mwen ap fe la paske mwen pa konnen moun ki rele "Dezagreman" ni an blan ni an nwa, ni an koule, ni an paint, ni an painti.
Rod konsantre li sou mo "neg sot" la e fe yon "spin" e li vire baz sije sou pitit hero indepandans nou yo.
Se pa paske yon moun se desandan Dessalines ou byen Petion ke moun nan automatkman gen "don" pou fe yon travay byen. Experians ak komesans konte tou!!
Map apiye sa moun Dezagreman di a se ke : Si yon moun pa gen ideoloji, visyon, devouman e kouraj pou pran desisyon pou tet W, fanmi W e peyi W, e byen travay lideship la ap tre difisil pou fet.

Li kap fet wi, min lap tre difisil pou fet paske jan granmoun di a: sot pa touye, men lap fe W souyè.
Revelation

Ki sa "preparasyon" ye.Se kapab diskite a pwopo de Platon,Aristòt,Nietszche,Kant,Amhurabi?

Si se ta pou sa,ni Lula,ni Evo Morales pa t ap ka prezidan;byen ke 2 nèg sa yo ,si yo te ayisyen,se ta bliye sa.
Lula ,se 5 an edikasyon fòmèl li genyen e Morales limenm ,li pa t rive nan ekivalan twazyèm segondè ayisyen an.

E pitou gade dènye prezidan perou an.Misye te pwofesè Ekonomi Politik nan Stanford ,youn nan pi gwo Inivèsite Ameriken.
Nan dènye ane manda l,popilarite misye te anba10%.
Si misye se prezidan Dayiti li te ye ,nanpren jan pou misye pa ta pran yon koudeta (lol)

sasaye la?. Ki sa nou rele moun sot?
Ki sa nou rele preparasyon an? Prepare poukisa? Ki mod preparasyon nou vle? Ki le you moun prepare?

ki sa nou atan de you moun sot?
San malis wal tro vit. gade byen definisyon moun sot epi wa we si wap bay you moun sot dirijew?
Nou toujou gen tandans tode you bagay you moun di pou nou fe pase lide nou ki akote. Ou paret pafwa entelijan poufe bagay sa la.
Mwen eseye konpran ke pou ou moun sot se you moun ki pa fe anpil etid nan lekol nan linivesite. Mwen kwe nan kreyol yo bal sans saa tou. Joel edem sim manti.
Si you moun konplekse paske li pat sobon, li pa dwe fe sa sevi you pot soti poul atake lot ki te etidye la. Se you konpleks denferyorite pou nou defoule nou ak hen ki nan ke nou kont moun ki reyisi fe sa nou pat gen petet mwayen pou fe (ekonomik ou byen sevo pou sa). Se you jalouzi

Ti papa mete dlo nan kleren w tande ,jalousi pouki sa?mwen pa deja di nou ke moun mwen admire anpil you se pa moun ki genyen diplom selman pou meprise lot moun.Men se moun ki kreye byen ak servis pou moun parey yo.

men yon nonm sot kritike UEH la al li atik nan Le matin pou konprann byen genyen yon seri ti pretansye ki ap rele moun moun sot men se de mo franse yo ka kole epi se lè yo pa genyen yon chek nan yon ministè ke yo rele dirijan ki ap dirije peyi ya moun sot.Lè jean claude duvalier tap dirije peyi ya yo pat janm wè li se moun sot paske li pat ale nan iniversite. ;men jodya paske yo pap souse manmel bef la tout moun ki nan gouvènman an se moun sot pou yo. Menmsi Jacques Edouard Alexis te rektè iniversite menm si Preval se agronom ki etidye an belgique ,menmsi Aristide genyen yon doktora sa pa genyen valè pou yo paske li se se pitit so yet neg an deyo.

la Sorbonne pa bay plis Prix Nobel ke State university of new York poukisa pou nou ta genyen diplome la Sorbonne yo jalousi la.La Sorbonne pa pi gwo universite ke New York Uiversity .Keen te pibliye non pi gwo iniversite yo mwen kwè la Sorbonne se te swa 69 eme iniversite li te ye nan mond lan.

Ant doktè ki tap fè moun manje po patat Fort Dimanche ki ta ap fè ti moun di zan al wè ki jan yap fizye 2 jenn gason nan mi simityè ,ki te fè ekspoze kadav Yvon laraque nan kafou grand Rue ak wout Delmas ki te fè yon bann san manman al boule kay Paran francois Benoit ak tout paran li ,menm yon pitit li ki te la yo te pran pitit la ak Antoine Simon ki les kite pi edike?Moun ki ap kole de mo franse pou yo fè ayisyen bat bravo ak moun tankou Thomas Edson ,Frè Wright yo, chairman Microsoft la Bill Gates ki te abandone etid iniversitè li apre 2 zan ak ti met avoka ki pa konnen menm jan pou yo presante yon ka nan tribinal ki moun ki pi byen edike.Zafè moun sot la se bagay pou yo al di nan royom aveg yo a.kote moun sezi ke yo ka kole de mo franse byen.Bo isit se montre ki sa sa w aprann lan servi a sosyete a e peyi ya se sa ki konte.

moun ki konnen vre pa di moun ke yo sot.Dr Degraff ,Doktè dejean al anpil lot moun anko ki genyen bon jan edikatyon vre pap janm di yon moun se yon moun sot paske chak moun genyen itilite nan yon sosyete.Pou mwen yon bon boss mason itil plis ke yon injenyè medyok ki pa ka trase yon bon wout ou byen konstwi yon bon pon.Mwen di w anko edikatyon se yon bagay ki relatif.se pas ke ou genyen yon diplom ki pemet ou pratike medsinn ki fè ou edike. mwen sonje mwen tap komante yon doktè ki tap plede mete dlo nan piki pou ba malad ki genyen kansè pwostat nan Zonn fort Lauderdale la ;lè yo fout menot nan men li ,mwen te ap komante sa ak doktè mwen li dim Rod :Doktè saate resevwa enstriktyon poul pratike medsin men sa pa vle di li te edike.Eske yon doktè ki ap fè kadejak sou fsanm ki al konsilte lakay li se yon moun ki edike?Eske yon avoka volè se yon moun ki edike?

mwen fyè de tet mwen menm si mwen se te yon kordonye, yon ebenist , yon mekanisyen ,yon chapantye.mwen wè elktrisyen ki bokou pi ere pasde anpi, ti doktè, ti avoka met zabelbok bè a chat.

mwen pap konpare NY university al lasobon. Mwen te senpman fe remake ke petet se you jalouzi ki soti depi nan jenes nou. Konpleks la soti depi le nou te nan peyi nou kote la sobon te reprezante you paket bagay pou ou ki te etidye an ayiti. Se pa le ou rive isiut non ou devlope jalouzi saa. Se lew ou te nan peyiw. Ou te toujou ap reve kile pouw montre ke moun ki te pi fo pase yo lontan pa kanpe sou anyen kounye paske ou te al Ny univesite. Tout le ou tap etidye la se moun sa yo ki nan tet ou.
Sa te rivem tou lem mwen pak ka al st lwi. Mwen tap veye you okazyon nan you egzamen ofisyel poum bay pi bon randman ke yo e mwen te santim onore lem nan inivesite an ayiti ou byen isit lem we se ou ansyen elev st lwi ou byen kay me ki mandem poum esplike yo ou bagay. Gen you elev ki te fem we sakrifis ke map fe poum ede ansyen elev st lwi ak ka me nan inivesite se you fason pou mwen montre yo ke yo pa konen plis pasem.
Eskizem sim projte sa mwen te viv sou ou. Se konsa mwen panse mwen tap rayaji e se konsa mwen te reyaji. Tout fyete sa wap pale ya la se fason pouw retire konpleks sa.
Nan tan lontan bo lakay yo tpa bay sobon nan plis vale e ou te grandi konsa.

san malis an nou kite diskisyon sa li pap ede peyi ya

san malis li sa
L'Ecole des Mines vient de publier un classement international des établissements d'enseignement supérieur qui s'appuie sur l'analyse des diplômes obtenus par les dirigeants de Fortune Global 500. 5 écoles françaises figurent dans le top 10. Ce classement tente de gommer la mauvaise image des universités françaises donnée par le classement de référence de l'Université de Shanghai
Le classement des établissements d'enseignement supérieur publié par l'Ecole des Mines devrait mettre du baume au coeur des écoles hexagonales : si Harvard, l'université de Tokyo et Stanford s'arrogent les trois premières places, 5 d'entre elles figurent dans les 10 établissements qu'ont fréquenté le plus grand nombre de dirigeants des 500 plus grandes entreprises mondiales recensées par le "Fortune Global 500". L'Ecole polytechnique arrive en 4e position, suivie par HEC (5e), Sciences Po Paris (8e), l'ENA (9e) et l'Ecole des mines (10e).
Cinq autres établissements (l'INSEAD, L'université Paris Dauphine, l'Ecole centrale Paris, l'Ecole nationale supérieure des arts et métiers, et l'Ecole nationale supérieure d'électronique, d'informatique, d'hydraulique et les télécommunications) apparaissent également dans la liste des cent premiers mondiaux.
L'absence des grandes écoles corrigée
"Les résultats de cette enquête mettent en évidence l'excellente position des établissements français, explique Benoît Legais, directeur de l'Ecole des mines. Si le score obtenu était ramené à la taille, les grandes écoles françaises, et en particulier l'ENA et les Mines de Paris, seraient probablement en tête à l'échelle mondiale." L'enquête souligne par ailleurs que si on prenait en compte non pas les écoles de manière isolée mais l'ensemble des établissements regroupés au sein de ParisTech, celui-ci serait sur la première marche du podium.
La satisfaction des établissements hexagonaux est d'autant plus importante qu'une majorité de ceux qui sont cités ne figurent pas dans le classement des meilleures universités mondiales réalisé par l'université de Shanghai. Dans ce classement, désormais reconnu comme une référence dans le monde entier, la meilleure université française se retrouve à la 43° position. Les grandes écoles, à la notable exception de l'Ecole normale supérieure, sont totalement absentes. La publication de ce palmarès avait déclenché un vente de panique dans le monde de l'enseignement supérieur français. Des projets de classement alternatif avait été envisagés par d'autres institutions pour gommer la mauvaise image donnée dans le monde entier des universités et grandes écoles françaises.
Critères différents
"Nous n'avons pas pris les mêmes critères. Nous ne cherchions pas à évaluer l'excellence académique des établissements, mesurée par le nombre de prix Nobel ou les citations dans les revues scientifiques, mais la probabilité de nos étudiants de devenir les dirigeants des entreprises de premier rang mondial, ajoute Benoît Legais. Les deux classements sont en réalité liés : entre 63 % et 76 % des 500 dirigeants considérés par l'enquête de l'Ecole des mines ont également fréquenté un des établissements figurant dans le classement de Shanghai".
Dans un contexte de guerre des talents, l'Ecole des Mines souhaite s'appuyer sur son enquête pour attirer les étudiants français et étrangers. Reste que la population passée au crible est composée essentiellement de dirigeants formés il y a une vingtaine d'années. Depuis, les établissements ont fortement évolué. Ce classement reflète donc une situation passée qui n'apporte pas d'informations sur le devenir des étudiants actuellement formés.
D'autre part, même s'il met en évidence l'importance de formations complémentaires, type MBA, qui permet à Harvard et à l'INSEAD d'accroître le nombre de leurs diplômés. L'importance croissante de ces diplômes pourrait aussi modifier la donne. Enfin, ne s'appuyant que les dirigeants et non pas sur les comités de direction des plus grandes entreprises mondiales, il relative le poids de certaines universités scientifiques de premier rang mondial telle l'université de Cambridge (60ème position) qui fournissent un nombre importants de chercheurs et jouent un rôle de plus en plus important en matière d'innovation.

I think that there may be a flaw in your logic. a flaw that may be understood from the socio-cultural structure of france itself. LEGAIS mentions that ENA and other prestigious french universities figure in the top notch when it comes to alumni heading GLOBAL FORTUNE 500 companies.
it is worth noting that french society is elitist to the core, and that certain schools do enjoy historical and social advatages that do not correspond to their relative global productivity. remember that getting to the top in france has a lot to do with who one knows, and that getting in ENA for example has the same requirement; so heading a global 500 company in france may have little to do with financial innovation as taught in one of these elitist universities and more to do with who one knows. in other words, the high representation of ena graduates in the french global 500 companies may have little to with ena itself, and more to do with the socio-cultural structure of france itself.
in fact, legais' argument would carry more weight if ena graduates were significantly represented in global 500 companies beyond france's realm of influence; in other words, in ena graduates were heading companies in japan, china and india for example.
in fact, there is a canadian school of business that is second only to havard when it comes to alumni heading global 500 companies.
you see, the french argument may not be as strong as they claim it to be.

mwen asepte ke yon moun save san konsyans paka fe ayiti mashe, men yon moun konsyan san konesans paka fe peyi ya mashe nonplis. tou de bagay sa yo, konsyans ak konesans nesese pou fe peyi mashe.
wi, nan tan nap viv la, yon moun ki pa edike paka fe peyi ya mashe nan tan moden sa jan pou peyi ya mashe.

Keen

He is talking about "les dirigeants de Fortune Global 500"not of the 500 better companies of france.But which list reflects the real value of education that the alumni received?Should one consider the Shangai list or the one published by L'ecole des mines?

At any rate the goal of my remarks concerning the writings of certain so called"great haitian minds"so called intellectuals who pretend that only those who have studied in Europe are well prepared do not confirm by reality.I remember during a vacation in paris I was watching a program on television where a group of french scientists were applauding the americans'accomplishements in various scientific field as astrology, medical ,engineering etc.

As for your remarks concerning my jalousy of those who have studied in Sorbonne ,let me inform you comrade that immediately after my graduation from grammar school of the Christian brothers in Cap haitien I never have any desire to return to their institutions.My heroes have always been my ancestors and the 8 great americans.I never had any desire to study in france,even if I had the economic means.Perharps in Belgium or in any other coutry,but not in france.

When I was a very young kid the languages I was trying to speak were english and spanish ,believe it or not.I do not know if it were because of the corporal punishment I received from the french brothers for my difficulties in writing french properly ,but I did not like french at all

Do not try to project your complexes to other people;we do not have the same feelings toward our oppressors.Some of us will vow our gratitudes toward them until we die.others will remember the consequences of slavery and the hold-up.Ok brother.

keen

how do you explain Lula's reelection.Are we more educated than the brazilians who reelect him?Are we more educated than the Boliveans?Knowledge is a relative term. A diploma is not a guarantee of knowledge.Sometimes it could be an handicap to govern a country for the benefits of the majority.

If you were to choose between Abraham lincoln and Georges W.Bush who would be your choice?I do not know about you ,but my choice would be Abe;Yet he never frequented yale.He learned law by himself.I think in any debate between the two Lincoln would make Georges W looks silly.It is not in making c- in Georgetown university that make Collin Powell an educated man as Sam Donaldson ,once asked :How come a C student becomes the Secretary of State of the United States?"(lol)Collin Powel answered :"Only in America,Sam"

bagay Jackoti ekri a pwopo de klasman Inivèsite franse yo,pa koresponn ditou ak sa lòt franse ekri yomenm,franse ki espesyalis nan edikasyon.

Te gen youn ki di ,ke anpil paran nan boujwazi franse an ,ta pre pou yo vann yon moun nan fanmiy yo ,pou pitit yo al Harvard,Yale , MIT ,Stanford elatriye.

Si ou pran 3 inivèsite sa yo,Harvard,Yale ak MIT ,bidjè yo pi gwo ke tout Inivèsite franse yo KONBINE.

mwen pral chache atik ke Edikatè franse yo ekri sou Inivèsite franse yo.Na sezi.

Kant a Sòbòn menm,Inivèsite sa a se lonbraj sa li te ye ,ke li ye konnye an.
Nou pa menm bezwen pale de li ankò.

I also said in one of my texts that to govern a country someone needs certain knowledge ,but the knowledge that some haitian intellectuals are refering to as a prerequisite to be a good adminstrator or a good president is sometimes irrelevant.

One does not need a PHD in economics,in law or in public administration to be a good president.The knowledge that is really relevant is to know the people ,their culture ;their needs, their aspirations;know the country as it is and not as described in a book.i think one needs more good qualities :love, compassion,good morale,leadership. a good ability to communicate which is different of to write french well;patriotism, not nationalism.

One does not have to be a lawyer to recognize that the haitian Constitution of 1987 is not compatible with haiti's needs and means.it is ludicrous for a poor country like haiti to perform an election every two years to elect some Senators,members of casecs ,asecs etc.However the people who wrote the Constiution were intellectuals ,lawyers, politicians etc.Most haitians presidents are intellectuals ,why then the country is so poorly managed since its independance?How, after men Like Louis Borno , Stenio Vincent , francois Duvalier to cite just a few ,can we have this high rate of illiteracy,this high rate of proverty?If a high level of education from universities were the only prerequisite to be a good President ,haiti would be an eldorado during Francois duvalier's presidency.

The period from 1957 to 1986 was probably the most degrading of haitian history.It was during that period haitians start to abandon their country, that Graham Green wrote" the comedians";"Duvaliers and the tonton macoute."etc.it was shameful to see haitians arriving on the beaches of Florida as people who were running from hell.The country was becoming a desert .he continued the shameful practice of selling the haitian peasants as slaves to the owners of sugar cane plantations in the dominican Republic.Haitians were invading bahamas and all the other islands in the caribean because they could no longer live in their own country.

Rod said:

One does not need a PHD in economics, in law or in public administration to be a good president. The knowledge that is really relevant is to know the people, their culture; their needs, their aspirations; know the country as it is and not as described in a book. I think one need more good qualities: love, compassion, good morale, leadership. A good ability to communicate which to write French well is different of; patriotism, not nationalism.

I concur with your statement Rod, I also believe that this debate took a different turn here.
We are discussing “moun sot” in Kreyol which means “Lack of Judgment.
Someone who too often has took bad decisions; or has made statements without thinking.
Someone, who has made a lot of improvisation at the wrong time,
“Moun sot “does not mean a deficiency in academic level in this debate. It means lack of judgments.
A doctor, an engineer, a scientist, a Prime Minister, a president may act like a “moun sot”.
For illustration,
A Prime Minister who said: Nou fout tire deye yo tou, genyen tombe, genyen kouri” It’s a no no!!
A President who said: We want him [Ben Laden] dead or alive!! Or said: Stay the course while soldiers are dying; It’s a no no!!
A president who said: Se yon ti piti zwitt, yo pa anpil referring to an uprising!! Without assessing the situation is a no no!!
A candidate saying to the people after loosing the elections: Le chien retourne toujours a son vomissement” is a no no, a bad looser”
Running a traffic red-light while a cop is right behind you is a no no!!
A doctor who is stealing his patients’ insurance money is a no no!!
Having sex with a prostitute without a condom is playing Russian roulette with your life and your wife’s live is a no no!
Going to Dominican Republic many times and not visiting the Haitian community in the bateys just to show compassion and solidarity with our brothers and sisters who are working and living in a slavery condition is a no no!!

I can go on and on….
Sa pa gen anyen pou we avek lekol, nivo edikasyon etc..

Revelation

mwen kontan ou fè korektyon saa se vre entelijans pa koresponn ak nivo edikasyon.se pa paske yon moun genyen yon diplom ki vle di li se yon moun entelijan genyen se kopye yo kopye tout sik detid yo.

men fraz mwen site mwen konen ki jan moun lan te anploye se pou li denigre Preval ak jean bertrand Aristide ki menm si li genyen yon doktora pa janm anyen pou yo paske li se pitit so yet moun an deyo.Mwen konnen ki jan ti boujwa sa yo panse.Ansyen pitit pitit esklav tankou m ou byen pitit pitit blan mannann ki vle fè moun konprann yo se noble pitit Louis XV ak marie Antoinette.

Antansyon. Genyen yon diferans ant edikasyon e enstriksyon.

Enstriksyon se sa yon moun resevwa e retni pandan tout tan ou tal lekol.

Edikasyon se total enstriksyon mete avèk tout prensip sosyal ou relijye e ethik yon moun resevwa pendan tout vi l.

Sa kapab soti lan fanmi l, lan lot kou civik e moral...

Donk yon nèg gen dwa byen enstry, li konn anpil bagay, men li manke sou edikasyon ki se kijan ou aproche yon sijè.

Men yon istwa ke mwen konnen paske yon zanmi solid te rakonte m li.
Lan ane 70 yo, yon Ayisyen entelektyèl rive Pari kom anbasadè Ayiti an Frans.

Nou tout konn tande pale de nèg saa. Li ekri yon gwo liv istwa ak sosyolojy an 2 tom (tomes).

Lè l rive Pari, zanmi an tap pilote l, montre l kote la jwen magazen, libreri, inivèsite, biro leta, etc...

Lè fènwa komanse, anbasadè a mande zanmi an s'il konnen kote yon nèg kab al degaje l ak medam yo.

Misye mennen nèg la lan yon bòdèl. Grenn je anbasadè a louvri tankou de soukoup.

Li mande zanmi an: bèlfanm blan sayo, se bouzen yoye?
E ti blond saa, ou kwè mwen ta kapab........?

Zanmi an rete tann lè l fini. Nèg lan komanse danse, jestikile epi li komanse distribye Kat bizniss li ki di:

S.E. untel,
Ambassadeur d'Haiti.

sasaye, saw di ya se sa net. Epi mwen te mande pou joel edem nan jan nou defini moun sot an kreyol anvan nou konpran sa san malis te vle di paske mwen panse li te konprann li mal ou byen li te bal sans moun ki pa resevwa lenstriksyon

my argument is that legais has not shown that a significant number of non-french-based global 500 companies is headed by alumni of these prestigious french universities.

list of france-based global 500 companies:

• Aérospatiale
  
• Air France Group
  
• Alcatel
  
• Alstom
  
• AXA
  
• Banque National De Paris
  
• Bouygues
  
• Carrefour
  
• Cie Financière De Paribas
  
• CNP Assurances
  
• Crédit Agricole
  
• Crédit Lyonnais
  
• Électricité De France
  
• Elf Aquitaine
  
• France Télécom
  
• Gaz De France
  
• Groupama
  
• Groupe Auchan
  
• Groupe Caisse D'Épargne
  
• Groupe Casino
  
• Groupe Danone
  
• Groupe Pinault-Printemps
  
• L'Oréal
  
• La Poste
  
• Lafarge
  
• Lagardère Groupe
  
• Michelin
  
• Pechiney
  
• Peugeot
  
• Promodès
  
• Renault
  
• Rhône-Poulenc
  
• Saint-Gobain
  
• SNCF
  
• Société Générale
  
• Suez Lyonnaise Des Eaux
  
• Total Fina
  
• Usinor
  
• Vivendi
  

if legais compiles his list primarily from the above selective group, then his argument is not that strong.
the above list is made of global 500 companies but they are based in france, and their heads will more than likely be french- after all, french people tend to display explicit xenophobia and strong nationalism.

You are right;it is a known fact that french society offers less opportunities to foreigners,particularly in the upper echelon of the public and private administration than the united States and Germany, according to a friend of mine who lives in france.Therefore it is obvious that the french companies that are listed in the fortune 500 global companies will be managed by a French CEO.

That does not necessarily mean that the french PDG are better prepared than a japanese or american CEO.One can look at the performances of companies like Renauldt ,Peugeot in the cars market of the United states to evaluate the performances of the CEO of these companies .Whereas new companies like Toyota, Hunday ,Honda, are selling thousands of cars every day in the United States ;how many cars are the french selling in the world market?Is it really because these new companies produce better cars than Peugeot and Renault;or because the marketing department of the french companies are not agressive enough?Why the german companies are selling so many cars in the United Sates ;Audi ,mercedes benz etc?pale franseuuu pa vle di lespri.(lol)

Après la confession de l'ancien President Jean Claude Duvalier ,certains rats du neo-duvalierisme abandonnent le bateau.Ils font pitié et n'inspirent que du mepris.

Après avoir chanté les louanges à la gloire de Lucifer ,ils condamnent maintenant ses crimes.J'avais bien dit à Rico qu'il ne pouvait pas convaincre des loups assoiffés de sang et des bergers allemands dressés uniquement pour garder la maison du maitre de repentir .Il aura fallu la repentance de jean claude Duvalier pour arrèter leur rage contre l'un des victimes de la demence d'un President tout puissant.

Incapables de comprendre les souffrances de Rico il le ridiculisent parce que la compassion ne peut pas atteindre ceux qui agissent simplement par instinct ,meme s'ils ont la faculte des perroquets.Je ne devrais pas defendre Rico ,mais je ne peux pas comprendre la fureur de ces loups qui montrent leur dents pour intimider ceux qui ne veulent pas s'agenouiller pour solliciter les faveurs de leur saint .

On pourrait admirer leur loyaute si seulement ils etaient plus discrets;pourquoi veulent-ils que les victimes adressent aussi des louanges à leurs maitres

Keen, I'm not sure your arguments are strong enough even though you might be right at some points. There are different ways to look at it. Out of those 500 companies, how many of them are France- based? If it happens to have 5 french universities in the top 10, it might show the french universities are quite good, but if we consider San malis point, there is something wrong in the system unless the USA market is not the priority of the french companies. San malis I think you are right on that.
Keen like I told you this morning I think the french came with that list to respond to the one from Shangai university.